By-law Amending the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance: SOR/2026-232

Canada Gazette, Part II, Volume 160, Number 23

Registration
SOR/2026-232 November 3, 2026

CANADIAN PAYMENTS ACT

The Board of Directors of the Canadian Payments Association makes the annexed By-law Amending the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance under subsection 18(1)footnote a of the Canadian Payments Act footnote b.

Ottawa, August 21, 2026

Kevan Cowan
Chairperson of the Board of Directors of the Canadian Payments Association

The Minister of Finance, under subsection 18(2)footnote c of the Canadian Payments Act footnote b, approves the annexed By-law Amending the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance, made by the Board of Directors of the Canadian Payments Association.

Ottawa, October 26, 2026

François-Philippe Champagne
Minister of Finance

By-law Amending the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance

Amendments

1 (1) The definitions committee, item in dispute and non-member in subsection 1(1) of the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance footnote 1 are replaced by the following:

committee
means a committee established by the Association or a subcommittee of that committee. (comité)
item in dispute
has the meaning assigned by the rules. (effet contesté)
non-member
means a local that is not a member and belongs to a central or cooperative credit association that is a member. (non-membre)

(2) The definition party in subsection 1(1) of the English version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

party
means a person that, under section 10, is a party to an investigation. (partie)

2 The heading before section 2 of the French version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Enquête à l’initiative du président

3 (1) Subsection 2(1) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Initiated by President

2 (1) The President may, at any time, if the President reasonably believes that a member or non-member has committed a contravention,

(2) Subsection 2(2) of the By-law is amended by striking out “and” at the end of paragraph (c) and by adding the following after that paragraph:

(3) Subsection 2(3) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Notice

(3) If the President decides to investigate a matter or refer a matter to a committee, the President must give written notice of that decision to the parties. The notice must contain the details of the alleged contravention.

Referral during investigation

(4) At any time during an investigation under paragraph (1)(a), the President may refer the matter, for the purposes of an investigation, to a committee that has relevant expertise. The President must give written notice of the referral to the parties.

4 Paragraph 3(2)(d) of the English version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

5 (1) Paragraph 6(1)(a) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

(2) Paragraph 6(1)(b) of the English version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

(3) Subsection 6(2) of the French version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Avis

(2) Le président, qu’il décide de mener l’enquête lui-même ou de renvoyer la plainte à un comité, en donne un avis écrit aux parties dans les trente jours suivant la date de dépôt de la plainte. L’avis contient un énoncé détaillé de la plainte.

(4) Subsection 6(3) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Referral to committee

(3) The referral of a complaint to a committee under paragraph (1)(b) must be made within 40 days after the day on which the complaint is filed.

Referral during investigation

(4) At any time during an investigation under paragraph (1)(a), the President may refer the complaint, for the purposes of an investigation, to a committee that has relevant expertise. The President must give written notice of the referral to the parties.

6 The portion of subsection 8(1) of the By-law before paragraph (a) is replaced by the following:

Duties

8 (1) If a matter or complaint has been referred to a committee, the committee must, no later than at its next regular meeting,

7 Subsection 9(2) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Conflict of interest

(2) If the President or a member of a compliance panel has, or appears to have, a conflict of interest, the President or the compliance panel member, as the case may be, must withdraw from the investigation and

8 Subsection 10(2) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Association

(2) Subject to subsection (3), the Association is a party to every investigation other than one conducted by the President under paragraph 2(1)(a).

9 Section 15 of the By-law is amended by adding the following after subsection (4):

Non-application — investigation by President

(5) This section does not apply to an investigation conducted by the President under paragraph 2(1)(a).

10 The By-law is amended by adding the following after section 15:

Investigation by President — response

15.1 (1) The parties to an investigation conducted by the President under paragraph 2(1)(a) may, within 10 days after the day on which the notice referred to in subsection 2(3) is given, provide a response in writing and any information or documents that are relevant to the investigation.

Acknowledgement of receipt

(2) The President must acknowledge, in writing, receipt of the response and any information or documents provided by the parties.

Decision

(3) The President must render a decision in writing and provide a copy to the parties within 20 days after the day on which the notice referred to in subsection 2(3) is given.

Decision — contents

(4) The decision must contain the following information:

Review of President’s decision

15.2 (1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3), a party may, within 30 days after the day on which a copy of the President’s decision is provided to the parties in accordance with subsection 15.1(3), make a request in writing to the President to have the decision reviewed by a compliance panel.

Request by clearing member

(2) A non-member is not permitted to make a request for review, but such a request may be made by the non-member’s clearing member.

Payment of penalty — no review

(3) A member that is subject to an order issued under paragraph 16(1)(f) to pay a penalty is not permitted to request a review of the President’s decision if the penalty has been paid in whole or in part.

Acknowledgement of receipt

(4) The President must acknowledge, in writing, receipt of the request for review.

Referral

(5) Within five days after the day on which the request for review is received, the President must refer the request, for the purposes of a review of the decision, to a committee that has relevant expertise.

Application and non-application of certain provisions

(6) Sections 8 and 9, subsection 10(1) and sections 11, 13, 14 and 16 apply to a review, with any necessary modifications, but sections 12 and 15 do not apply to a review.

Request for review — submissions

(7) A party must be given the opportunity to make written submissions without introducing new evidence.

Review

(8) The compliance panel must review the submissions as well as the written response and any information and documents provided under subsection 15.1(1).

Powers of review

(9) After the review, the compliance panel must determine whether a contravention has occurred and may

Decision

(10) The compliance panel must render its decision in writing and provide a copy to the parties within 30 days after the day on which the compliance panel is established.

Decision — contents

(11) The compliance panel’s decision must contain the following information:

11 Paragraph 16(1)(f) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

12 The portion of section 17 of the French version of the By-law before paragraph (a) is replaced by the following:

Frais

17 Le président ou le groupe de contrôle, selon le cas, peut déterminer le montant des frais de l’enquête et ordonner que l’une ou l’autre des personnes suivantes ou les deux en paient la totalité ou une partie :

13 Section 18 of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Compliance

18 (1) Every member that is subject to an order issued under paragraph 15.2(9)(c), subsection 16(1) or section 17 must comply with the order.

Investigation by President

(2) However, in cases where an order is issued in a decision rendered under subsection 15.1(3), the member is not required to comply with the order until the day after the day on which

14 (1) Subsection 19(1) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Investigation by President

19 (1) If an investigation is conducted by the President under paragraph 6(1)(a), the President must prepare a compliance report.

(2) Subsection 19(2) of the French version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Enquête menée par un groupe de contrôle

(2) Si l’enquête a été menée par un groupe de contrôle, celui-ci rédige un rapport sur la conformité.

15 Paragraphs 20(c) and (d) of the By-law are replaced by the following:

16 Section 22 of the By-law is amended by adding the following after subsection (1):

Investigation by President

(1.1) However, in cases where the amount to be paid is set out in a decision rendered under subsection 15.1(3), the amount is due within 30 days after the day on which

17 Subsection 24(1) of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Register

24 (1) Every decision or order of the Board made under subsection 7(9), every decision of the President rendered under subsection 15.1(3), every decision of the compliance panel rendered under subsection 15.2(10) and every compliance report prepared under section 19 must be filed with the Association and recorded in a register maintained by the secretary.

18 Subsection 26(1) of the French version of the By-law is replaced by the following:

Modes de communication

26 (1) Tout avis qui doit être donné conformément au présent règlement administratif est considéré comme donné s’il est remis au membre en main propre, transmis par télécopieur ou courrier électronique ou envoyé par courrier recommandé — sauf lorsque le service postal est interrompu ou risque de l’être à cause d’un conflit de travail — au destinataire et à l’adresse figurant sur la liste des membres ou aux registres de l’Association.

19 The English version of the By-law is amended by replacing “shall” with “must” in the following provisions:

Coming into Force

20 This By-law comes into force on the day on which it is registered.

REGULATORY IMPACT ANALYSIS STATEMENT

(This statement is not part of the By-law.)

Issues

The existing processes set out in the Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 6 — Compliance (the By-law) for investigating and addressing alleged contraventions can be onerous and time consuming and are not purpose-built for certain alleged contraventions, such as those that are simple or uncontested. The amendments to the By-law introduce an expedited process for the investigation of such alleged contraventions. The amendments also increase the maximum penalty amount to ensure that penalties continue to serve as an effective compliance tool.

Background

The Canadian Payments Association (doing business as Payments Canada) is a statutory corporation under the Canadian Payments Act (the Act) with a mandate to establish and operate national systems for the exchange, clearing and settlement of payments. The Act established Payments Canada and it establishes its mandate and duty, its governance structure, and eligibility for membership. Only members of Payments Canada are eligible to participate on its systems.

Payments Canada members and system participants must comply with the requirements set out in Payments Canada’s by-laws and rules, such as participation requirements and time frames for clearing and settlement of payment items. A contravention occurs when a member fails to comply with applicable requirements, such as a failure to follow security requirements for a payments system. The By-law sets out the processes for investigating and addressing alleged contraventions, including any sanctions that may be imposed if it is determined that a contravention has occurred. The existing processes for investigations are as follows:

When a matter or complaint is referred to a committee, the committee establishes a compliance panel to investigate. The President or compliance panel must hold a hearing unless those involved agree it is not necessary. Following an investigation by the President or a compliance panel, if it is determined there has been a contravention, sanctions may be imposed. Examples of sanctions include reprimanding the member and ordering the payment of a monetary penalty, as set out in the By-law. The President or the compliance panel may also require the payment of expenses of the investigation by one or both of: (1) the member who was subject to the investigation; or (2) the complainant who is a party to the investigation. As the existing processes can be time-consuming, a streamlined process will be more efficient and expeditious for the President to investigate certain alleged contraventions.

The amendments to the By-law

Objective

The amendments (1) introduce an expedited process for investigations by the President where it is generally more efficient and expeditious for the President to investigate the alleged contravention, and (2) ensure the continued effectiveness of the penalty amount as an appropriate enforcement tool to promote compliance.

Description

Investigation by the President

The amendments introduce an expedited process that allows the President, when they reasonably believe that a member has not complied with a requirement of the by-laws or rules, to investigate without referral to a committee, similar to the existing process for investigating member complaints. The new process allows the President to investigate matters under expedited time frames and without being required to convene a hearing.

In determining whether to investigate a matter under the expedited process, the President will take into account, among other things, the complexity of the matter, the severity of the matter and whether the alleged contravention is contested. The President may also consider other factors relevant to the unique circumstances of each matter. The criteria to be considered in making this determination are set out in a guideline published on Payments Canada’s website, developed in consultation with members and relevant stakeholders and approved by Payments Canada’s Board of Directors. This guideline will promote transparency and consistency in the use of the President’s expedited investigation process. If the President determines not to investigate the matter themself, that matter will be referred to a committee for the purposes of an investigation.

For investigations conducted by the President (either initiated by the President or through a complaint filed), the amendments allow the President to, at any point during the investigation, refer the issues to a committee for investigation, for example, if it is more complex than initially anticipated. Matters and complaints referred to a committee follow the existing investigation process set out in the By-law, including procedures for a hearing.

When the President initiates and conducts an investigation, a hearing will not take place. Other procedural rights set out in the By-law apply, including the right to a fair and impartial investigation. If a member disputes the President’s decision, the amendments introduce the right for a member to have the President’s decision reviewed by an independent compliance panel. In its review, the compliance panel will review the facts of the investigation and any submissions previously provided to determine if a contravention has occurred and either confirm, vary or set aside any sanctions and expenses imposed by the President.

Maximum penalty amount

Amendments to the By-law also increase the maximum penalty amount for each contravention from $250,000 to $1,000,000, which has remained unchanged since 1998. The increase in the penalty amount is reflective of inflation over time and of an amount intended to encourage compliance. Other existing sanctions, including reprimanding or suspending one or more rights of a member, remain the same. Penalty amounts are determined in accordance with guidance established by Payments Canada and available on its website, consistent with its current risk-based compliance approach.

Technical amendments

Technical changes have been made to update certain definitions in the By-law to align with recent amendments to the governing legislation and to reflect current practices.

Regulatory development

Consultation

Consultations prior to the prepublication in the Canada Gazette, Part I

In developing the proposed amendments, Payments Canada consulted its regulators, members and stakeholders, including targeted consultation with credit union locals, payment service providers, and clearing houses as well as the Member Advisory Council, Stakeholder Advisory Council, Legal and Policy Group, and Senior Operational Committee. Entities engaged showed support for the policy proposals and amendments to the By-law.

A 30-day public consultation was held, between February 4 and March 6, 2025, seeking views on the policy proposals to introduce an expedited process for addressing alleged contraventions that are straightforward or uncontested and to increase the maximum penalty amount to $1,000,000. The consultation revealed support for an expedited process to investigate simple or uncontested contraventions as well as an increase to the maximum penalty amount from members, credit union locals, payment service providers, clearing houses, and consumer groups.

Prepublication in the Canada Gazette, Part I

The proposed amendments to the By-law were published in the Canada Gazette, Part I, on October 11, 2025, for a 30-day comment period. During this time, comments were received from four interested parties, consisting of three industry associations and one individual. Payments Canada met with two industry associations to clarify the intent of the proposed amendments and to gather additional details related to their comments. All industry associations showed support for the proposed amendments, including the expedited investigation process, with some suggested changes and additional considerations. All feedback has been duly considered.

Feedback resulting in changes to the By-law following prepublication

Some interested parties sought clarity as it relates to the review process. One association sought clarity on the powers of the compliance panel as part of a review, specifically whether a compliance panel may request new information and, if so, whether the compliance panel should have the power to conduct a hearing. Another respondent requested additional clarity regarding the possible outcomes of a review. The ability of the compliance panel to request additional information or documents has been removed to reflect the intent of the review and administrative amendments have been made to clarify the contents of the compliance panel’s decision and promote consistency with existing By-law provisions.

Feedback that did not result in changes to the By-law following prepublication

The industry associations recommended that Payments Canada clarify the scope of the President’s discretion to investigate, such as specifying that it only applies to uncontested and straightforward matters, and noted that this determination should be made on a rational basis. They also recommended providing objective and measurable criteria to guide the President in determining whether to investigate a matter.

During follow-up conversations with industry associations, Payments Canada clarified that the expedited process will be used to investigate alleged contraventions that would benefit from faster and more efficient resolution, such as those that are straightforward or uncontested. Additionally, Payments Canada clarified that the criteria to be considered by the President in determining whether to investigate a matter under the expedited process would be set out in a publicly available guideline. Industry associations showed support for this approach. Payments Canada has developed a guideline that incorporates the criteria and is available on Payments Canada’s website. Therefore, no further amendments to the By-law were made.

One association suggested that the By-law clarify that if a party pays the penalty, they are deemed to have committed the contravention. Payments Canada considered this suggestion but found this change to be unnecessary, as the President determines whether a contravention has occurred and a penalty would only be imposed if a member is found to be in contravention. The same association also provided feedback about operational challenges due to the use of calendar days as opposed to business days. Payments Canada considered this suggestion but has not made any changes, as the process is intended to be expeditious and the use of calendar days is consistent with existing time frames set out in the By-law.

One association recommended that Payments Canada publish anonymized summaries of decisions made after an investigation. Payments Canada has not made any changes to the By-law but has considered other mechanisms to address this recommendation. The same industry association recommended that Payments Canada publish clear guidance on how penalties will be determined. No changes have been made to the By-law as Payments Canada has published guidance on how penalties are determined on its website.

Indigenous engagement, consultation and modern treaty obligations

The amendments have no impact on modern treaty obligations, and the launch of the Indigenous engagement and consultation process is not required.

Instrument choice

There are no instrument alternatives available for Payments Canada. The amendments must be made by way of a by-law amendment.

Regulatory analysis

Benefits and costs

The amendments to introduce a new process for investigating alleged contraventions will decrease the administrative burden on Payments Canada and on the members that otherwise would be required to participate in an investigation process involving a hearing. The new process enables Payments Canada to expedite the investigation process, where applicable. The benefit cannot be monetized, as it is administrative in nature.

The increased maximum penalty amount is intended to promote compliance. The increased maximum penalty amount will result in additional costs to members in the event of a contravention, resulting in a penalty being imposed at a higher level than allowed today following an investigation. However, the costs and benefits related to the increase in the maximum penalty amount are not considered costs nor benefits within the scope of the regulatory analysis, since they occur only in instances of non-compliance with requirements set out in the by-laws and rules.

There are no costs to the Government or taxpayers. Payments Canada is a statutory corporation created by an Act of Parliament. It operates on a not-for-profit basis and recovers its costs through transaction fees and common services dues levied on its members.

Small business lens

Analysis under the small business lens determined that the amendments are unlikely to result in costs for small businesses. Small businesses that are eligible for membership may choose to apply to become a member of Payments Canada. For a small business that becomes a member and is alleged to be in contravention, the new process will lessen the administrative burden associated with an investigation involving a hearing. Based on current interests and the number of small businesses eligible for membership, the annualized net impact on small businesses is expected to be $0.

The amendments to increase the maximum penalty amount will not impose an administrative or compliance burden on Canadian small businesses. Contraventions are not considered to be an administrative or a compliance burden for the purpose of the small business lens.

One-for-one rule

The one-for-one rule applies, since there is an incremental decrease in the administrative burden on business. The new process for investigating alleged contraventions will decrease the administrative burden on members that otherwise would participate in the current investigation process involving a hearing. The amendments are considered a burden OUT under the rule, and no regulatory titles are repealed or introduced. The amendments will result in an annualized administrative total cost savings of $1,388.

As per the Red Tape Reduction Regulations, the assessment of administrative impacts was conducted for a period of 10 years commencing from registration. All values listed in this section are presented in 2012 dollars, discounted to 2012 at a rate of 7%.

The amendments related to the introduction of a new investigation procedure represent an annualized total cost savings of $1,388. Up to 10 businesses would save five hours by not having to participate in a hearing once per year. The average wage (including overhead) of the responsible individual is estimated to be $61.80.

The amendments to increase the maximum penalty amount have no incremental change in the administrative burden on businesses. Contraventions are not considered to be an administrative burden for the purpose of the one-for-one rule.

Regulatory cooperation and alignment

The amendments are not related to any commitments with regard to regulatory cooperation or alignment.

Effects on the environment

No environmental or economic effects have been identified.

Gender-based analysis plus

No impacts based on gender and other identity factors have been identified.

Rationale

The amendments to the By-law are made to ensure that Payments Canada’s compliance framework and tools are effective in promoting compliance. This will achieve the stated objectives.

Implementation, compliance and enforcement, and service standards

The amendments to the By-law come into force on the day it is registered. Following the publication of the amendments to the By-law in the Canada Gazette, Part II, Payments Canada will publish the amendments to the By-law on its website to promote member and stakeholder awareness.

Once the amendments to the By-law are in force, the President, when they reasonably believe a contravention has been committed, will apply the criteria set out in the guideline to determine whether to investigate the matter or refer it to a committee for the purposes of an investigation. The criteria to be considered by the President in making this determination is set out in a guideline published on Payments Canada’s website. Similarly, the guidance relating to how penalties are determined and applied to a member found to be in contravention is available on Payments Canada’s website.

Payments Canada is responsible for ensuring that its members comply with the by-laws, as applicable. The amendments do not require any new mechanisms to ensure compliance and enforcement.

Contact

Stephanie Mould
Vice-President
Compliance, Privacy and Bank of Canada Affairs
Canadian Payments Association
Constitution Square, Tower II
350 Albert Street, Suite 800
Ottawa, Ontario
K1R 1A4
Email: smould@payments.ca